How ironic that the first person to vote is the name I drew!
Seriously, I tossed the papers, closed my eyes, then drew a name. Carlye will be the proud owner of a Caribou or Starbucks gift card - it's her choice. More contests to come though, so don't be afraid to comment!!! And, I think I'm going to go with Option B, it won the most votes and it was my favorite from the beginning. Thanks for all the input!